fix(env): flag combinations for sandboxes (#6308)

* fix(env): flag combinations for sandboxes

* more changes

Author: icecrasher321

apps/docs/content/docs/en/platform/enterprise/self-hosted.mdx

@@ -23,7 +23,10 @@ ENTERPRISE_ENABLED=true
 NEXT_PUBLIC_ENTERPRISE_ENABLED=true
 ```
 
-That turns on organizations, permission groups, SSO, whitelabeling, audit logs, session policies, data retention, data drains, workspace forks, sandboxes, and the inbox.
+That turns on organizations, permission groups, SSO, whitelabeling, audit logs,
+session policies, data retention, data drains, workspace forks, the Sandbox
+entitlement, and the inbox. Sandboxes remain unavailable until their remote
+provider and dedicated Function base are configured.
 
 ### Turning one feature off
 
@@ -95,9 +98,16 @@ NEXT_PUBLIC_SANDBOXES_ENABLED=true
 ```
 
 `SANDBOXES_ENABLED` grants the server-side self-hosted entitlement.
-`NEXT_PUBLIC_SANDBOXES_ENABLED` exposes remote Python and Shell plus custom
-sandbox management in the browser. Set the public flag only after the selected
-provider has credentials and a valid immutable Function base configured.
+`NEXT_PUBLIC_SANDBOXES_ENABLED` projects provider readiness to the browser and
+exposes Shell plus custom Sandbox management. Set the public flag only after the
+selected provider has credentials and a valid immutable Function base configured.
+The Function language value itself is never conditioned on these flags, so a
+saved Python block cannot be silently serialized or executed as JavaScript.
+
+JavaScript without `import` or `require` does not use this remote provider and
+continues to run in the local isolated VM when all Sandbox flags are off. Python,
+Shell, JavaScript with external imports, and selected custom Sandboxes fail with
+an explicit configuration error until the remote Function base is ready.
 
 Mothership's `function_execute` and `run_code` tools use Mothership's separate
 shell image, including for JavaScript without imports. If the deployment uses

apps/docs/content/docs/en/platform/self-hosting/index.mdx

@@ -119,12 +119,11 @@ Sim is self-contained for the core editor and execution engine. A few features r
 | **Agent blocks** | An API key for at least one model provider | Or a self-hosted OpenAI-compatible endpoint: Ollama, vLLM, or LiteLLM. |
 | **Chat module** | `COPILOT_API_KEY` from sim.ai | Set `NEXT_PUBLIC_CHAT_DISABLED=true` to hide the module instead. |
 | **Integrations** | Your own OAuth app per service | See [Integrations & OAuth](/platform/self-hosting/integrations-oauth). |
-| **Function / Pi blocks at scale** | Optional E2B or Daytona key | Without one, code runs in the in-process isolated-vm sandbox. See [Security](/platform/self-hosting/security). |
+| **Remote Function / Pi execution** | Optional E2B or Daytona key | Without one, JavaScript Function code that has no `import` or `require` still runs in the in-process isolated VM. Python, Shell, JavaScript with external imports, custom Function Sandboxes, and Pi require a configured remote provider. See [Security](/platform/self-hosting/security). |
 
 <FAQ items={[
   { question: "What are the minimum requirements to self-host Sim?", answer: "At minimum you need 2 CPU cores, 12 GB RAM, 20 GB SSD storage, and Docker 20.10 or later. Memory is typically the constraining factor due to workflow execution (isolated-vm sandboxing), file processing, and vector operations (pgvector)."},
   { question: "What are the required environment variables for production?", answer: "Three secrets are required: BETTER_AUTH_SECRET (authentication), ENCRYPTION_KEY (data encryption), and INTERNAL_API_SECRET (service-to-service auth). Generate each with openssl rand -hex 32. You also need to set NEXT_PUBLIC_APP_URL and BETTER_AUTH_URL to your domain."},
   { question: "Can I use Sim with local AI models?", answer: "Yes. Sim supports Ollama for local model inference. Use docker-compose.ollama.yml instead of docker-compose.prod.yml. It offers both GPU (with NVIDIA support) and CPU-only profiles, and automatically pulls gemma3:4b as a starter model." },
 ]} />
 
-

apps/docs/content/docs/en/platform/self-hosting/security.mdx

@@ -115,7 +115,9 @@ Workflows can execute user-authored JavaScript and Python. Know which sandbox yo
 | **E2B** | `E2B_ENABLED=true`, `E2B_API_KEY` | Remote sandbox per execution. Strongest isolation; requires outbound access to E2B. |
 | **Daytona** | `SANDBOX_PROVIDER=daytona`, `DAYTONA_API_KEY` | Remote sandbox per execution. |
 
-Python execution and the tooling-dependent blocks require a remote sandbox provider — the in-process isolate runs JavaScript only.
+Python, Shell, JavaScript with external imports, and tooling-dependent blocks
+require a remote sandbox provider. JavaScript without `import` or `require`
+continues to run in the in-process isolate when no remote provider is configured.
 
 <Callout type="warn">
   With the default in-process sandbox, treat everyone who can author a workflow as someone running code in your app container's security context. If your Sim instance is open to a wide or partly-trusted audience, use a remote sandbox provider and enable the NetworkPolicy egress restrictions.

apps/docs/content/docs/en/workflows/blocks/function.mdx

@@ -16,7 +16,11 @@ The **Function block** runs your own JavaScript, Python, or Shell code as one st
 
 ### Code
 
-JavaScript is the default. Python and Shell appear when a remote sandbox provider is enabled. Reference an earlier output directly, with no quotes around the tag, and read an environment variable with `{{VAR}}`:
+JavaScript is the default. The language field is part of the saved workflow and is
+never removed when Sandbox configuration changes. Python remains available as a
+language choice; Shell and custom Sandbox controls appear when a remote Function
+sandbox provider is enabled. Reference an earlier output directly, with no quotes
+around the tag, and read an environment variable with `{{VAR}}`:
 
 <Tabs items={['JavaScript', 'Python', 'Shell']}>
   <Tab value="JavaScript">
@@ -98,6 +102,13 @@ on a self-hosted instance, build and configure the provider's dedicated
 generate are captured as images automatically.
 </Callout>
 
+<Callout type="info">
+If no remote provider is configured, JavaScript without `import` or `require`
+continues to run in Sim's local isolated VM. Missing E2B or Daytona configuration
+does not disable that path. Remote-only code fails with an explicit configuration
+error; Sim does not reinterpret Python or Shell as JavaScript.
+</Callout>
+
 The dedicated Function base has the same runtime and universal package contract
 on E2B and Daytona. It includes this data-science stack; use a workspace sandbox
 when another dependency must be present:
@@ -128,7 +139,9 @@ Create and edit sandboxes in **Settings → Sandboxes**. Only workspace admins c
 create or edit them. On sim.ai they need an active Max or Enterprise plan;
 self-hosted deployments turn them on with `SANDBOXES_ENABLED` (see
 [self-hosted enterprise](/platform/enterprise/self-hosted)). The section is
-hidden when a deployment has no sandbox provider configured.
+usable only when the deployment also has a remote provider and immutable Function
+base configured. The Function block hides its custom Sandbox selector when that
+runtime is unavailable.
 
 1. **Name** the sandbox — `bigquery-etl`, `scraping`, whatever the job is.
 2. Pick the **language**. This selects pip or npm for the dependency list. Python
@@ -363,8 +376,9 @@ The lazy `sim.files` and `sim.values` helpers are available only in JavaScript f
 - **Use stdout to debug.** `console.log()`, `print()`, and ordinary shell output land in `<function.stdout>` and the run logs.
 
 <FAQ items={[
-  { question: "What languages does the Function block support?", answer: "JavaScript, Python, and Shell. JavaScript is the default. Python and Shell appear when a remote sandbox provider is enabled." },
+  { question: "What languages does the Function block support?", answer: "JavaScript, Python, and Shell. JavaScript is the default. Python remains a stable saved language choice; Shell and custom Sandbox controls appear when a remote sandbox provider is enabled. Python and Shell execution require that provider." },
   { question: "When does code run locally vs. in a sandbox?", answer: "JavaScript without external imports runs in a local isolated sandbox for speed. JavaScript that uses import or require, Python, and Shell run in the configured remote sandbox." },
+  { question: "Does JavaScript still work without E2B or Daytona?", answer: "Yes. JavaScript without import or require runs in Sim's local isolated VM and does not require a remote provider. JavaScript with external imports, Python, Shell, and custom Sandboxes require E2B or Daytona and fail explicitly when it is unavailable." },
   { question: "How do I reference outputs from other blocks inside my code?", answer: "Use angle-bracket syntax directly, like <agent.content> or <api.data>, with no quotes around the tag — Sim replaces it with the real value before execution. For environment variables, use double curly braces: {{API_KEY}}." },
   { question: "What does the Function block return?", answer: "Two outputs: result and stdout. Use return in JavaScript, assign __sim_result__ in Python, or print an __SIM_RESULT__= marker in Shell to set result. Ordinary console, print, and command output goes to stdout." },
   { question: "Can I make HTTP requests from a Function block?", answer: "Yes. fetch() is available in JavaScript with async/await. In Python, use requests or httpx. In Shell, use curl or a CLI available on the selected sandbox." },

apps/sim/app/api/function/execute/route.test.ts

@@ -218,7 +218,7 @@ describe('Function Execute API Route', () => {
       expect(data).toHaveProperty('error', 'Unauthorized')
     })
 
-    it.concurrent('should use isolated-vm for secure sandboxed execution', async () => {
+    it('runs import-free JavaScript in isolated-vm without a remote provider', async () => {
       const req = createMockRequest('POST', {
         code: 'return "test"',
       })
@@ -229,6 +229,9 @@ describe('Function Execute API Route', () => {
       expect(response.status).toBe(200)
       expect(data.success).toBe(true)
       expect(data.output.result).toBe('test')
+      expect(mockExecuteInIsolatedVM).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1)
+      expect(mockExecuteInSandbox).not.toHaveBeenCalled()
+      expect(mockExecuteShellInSandbox).not.toHaveBeenCalled()
     })
 
     it('does not accept a Mothership sandbox profile from the request body', async () => {

apps/sim/blocks/blocks.test.ts

@@ -340,7 +340,7 @@ describe.concurrent('Blocks Module', () => {
         const languageSubBlock = block?.subBlocks.find((sb) => sb.id === 'language')
         const codeSubBlock = block?.subBlocks.find((sb) => sb.id === 'code')
         const sandboxSubBlock = block?.subBlocks.find((sb) => sb.id === 'sandboxId')
-        expect(languageSubBlock?.showWhenEnvSet).toBe('NEXT_PUBLIC_SANDBOXES_ENABLED')
+        expect(languageSubBlock?.showWhenEnvSet).toBeUndefined()
         expect(sandboxSubBlock?.showWhenEnvSet).toBe('NEXT_PUBLIC_SANDBOXES_ENABLED')
         expect(codeSubBlock).toBeDefined()
         expect(codeSubBlock?.type).toBe('code')

apps/sim/blocks/blocks/function.ts

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 import { CodeIcon } from '@/components/icons'
-import { getEnv, isTruthy } from '@/lib/core/config/env'
+import { isSandboxesEnabled } from '@/lib/core/config/env-flags'
 import { CodeLanguage, getLanguageDisplayName } from '@/lib/execution/languages'
 import {
   fetchWorkspaceSandboxOption,
@@ -34,13 +34,12 @@ export const FunctionBlock: BlockConfig<CodeExecutionOutput> = {
       options: () => [
         { label: getLanguageDisplayName(CodeLanguage.JavaScript), id: CodeLanguage.JavaScript },
         { label: getLanguageDisplayName(CodeLanguage.Python), id: CodeLanguage.Python },
-        ...(isTruthy(getEnv('NEXT_PUBLIC_SANDBOXES_ENABLED'))
+        ...(isSandboxesEnabled
           ? [{ label: getLanguageDisplayName(CodeLanguage.Shell), id: CodeLanguage.Shell }]
           : []),
       ],
       placeholder: 'Select language',
       value: () => CodeLanguage.JavaScript,
-      showWhenEnvSet: 'NEXT_PUBLIC_SANDBOXES_ENABLED',
     },
     {
       id: 'code',

apps/sim/lib/billing/core/subscription.test.ts

@@ -336,16 +336,15 @@ describe('hasWorkspaceLiveSyncAccess', () => {
   })
 })
 
-/**
- * Sandboxes are an enterprise feature, so `SANDBOXES_ENABLED` must win over the
- * plan gate the way `INBOX_ENABLED` does. Both cases run with billing enabled —
- * the `!isBillingEnabled` bail would otherwise answer every one of them, hiding
- * whether the override is wired at all.
- */
 describe('hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess', () => {
   beforeEach(() => {
     vi.clearAllMocks()
-    setEnvFlags({ isBillingEnabled: true, isHosted: true, isSandboxesEnabled: false })
+    setEnvFlags({
+      isBillingEnabled: true,
+      isHosted: true,
+      isSandboxDeploymentEntitled: false,
+      isSandboxesEnabled: true,
+    })
     mockGetWorkspaceWithOwner.mockResolvedValue({
       id: 'workspace-host',
       billedAccountUserId: 'workspace-owner',
@@ -361,17 +360,23 @@ describe('hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess', () => {
     })
   })
 
-  afterAll(() => setEnvFlags({ isSandboxesEnabled: true }))
+  it('fails closed before resolving a payer when the remote feature is unavailable', async () => {
+    setEnvFlags({ isSandboxesEnabled: false })
 
-  it('grants access from the self-hosted override without resolving a payer', async () => {
-    setEnvFlags({ isSandboxesEnabled: true })
+    await expect(hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess('workspace-host')).resolves.toBe(false)
+    expect(mockGetWorkspaceWithOwner).not.toHaveBeenCalled()
+    expect(mockGetHighestPriorityPersonalSubscription).not.toHaveBeenCalled()
+  })
+
+  it('grants an explicit deployment override without resolving a payer', async () => {
+    setEnvFlags({ isSandboxDeploymentEntitled: true })
 
     await expect(hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess('workspace-host')).resolves.toBe(true)
     expect(mockGetWorkspaceWithOwner).not.toHaveBeenCalled()
     expect(mockGetHighestPriorityPersonalSubscription).not.toHaveBeenCalled()
   })
 
-  it('falls back to the Max plan gate when the override is unset', async () => {
+  it('uses the Max plan gate on a billing-enabled deployment', async () => {
     mockGetHighestPriorityPersonalSubscription.mockResolvedValue({
       referenceId: 'workspace-owner',
       plan: 'pro_25000',
@@ -383,7 +388,7 @@ describe('hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess', () => {
     expect(mockGetHighestPriorityPersonalSubscription).toHaveBeenCalledWith('workspace-owner')
   })
 
-  it('denies a sub-Max payer when the override is unset', async () => {
+  it('denies a sub-Max payer on a billing-enabled deployment', async () => {
     mockGetHighestPriorityPersonalSubscription.mockResolvedValue({
       referenceId: 'workspace-owner',
       plan: 'pro_6000',
@@ -393,4 +398,22 @@ describe('hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess', () => {
 
     await expect(hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess('workspace-host')).resolves.toBe(false)
   })
+
+  it('requires an Enterprise or Sandbox deployment entitlement when billing is disabled', async () => {
+    setEnvFlags({
+      isBillingEnabled: false,
+      isSandboxDeploymentEntitled: false,
+      isSandboxesEnabled: false,
+    })
+
+    await expect(hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess('workspace-host')).resolves.toBe(false)
+
+    setEnvFlags({
+      isSandboxDeploymentEntitled: true,
+      isSandboxesEnabled: true,
+    })
+
+    await expect(hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess('workspace-host')).resolves.toBe(true)
+    expect(mockGetWorkspaceWithOwner).not.toHaveBeenCalled()
+  })
 })

apps/sim/lib/billing/core/subscription.ts

@@ -30,6 +30,7 @@ import {
   isBillingEnabled,
   isHosted,
   isInboxEnabled,
+  isSandboxDeploymentEntitled,
   isSandboxesEnabled,
   isSsoEnabled,
 } from '@/lib/core/config/env-flags'
@@ -691,11 +692,12 @@ export async function hasWorkspaceLiveSyncAccess(workspaceId: string): Promise<b
  * Checks whether the exact workspace payer can discover, author, or directly
  * select custom Sim sandboxes through Copilot.
  *
- * Same entitlement as the inbox (Sim Mailer), and the same shape: the
- * `SANDBOXES_ENABLED` self-hosted override wins first, then a deployment
- * without billing is unrestricted, and otherwise the workspace payer must hold
- * a usable Max or Enterprise subscription. Builds cost provider compute and
- * storage, so this deliberately sits above the plain paid tier.
+ * A configured remote Function provider is mandatory. On billing-free
+ * deployments, the Enterprise pair or Sandbox-specific pair grants access. With
+ * billing enabled, an explicit Sandbox deployment override wins; otherwise the
+ * workspace payer must hold a usable Max or Enterprise subscription. Builds cost
+ * provider compute and storage, so this deliberately sits above the plain paid
+ * tier.
  *
  * Existing Function execution deliberately does not consult it (see
  * `resolveWorkspaceSandbox`), so a workspace that downgrades keeps running the
@@ -704,8 +706,9 @@ export async function hasWorkspaceLiveSyncAccess(workspaceId: string): Promise<b
  */
 export async function hasWorkspaceSandboxAccess(workspaceId: string): Promise<boolean> {
   try {
-    if (isSandboxesEnabled) return true
-    if (!isBillingEnabled) return true
+    if (!isSandboxesEnabled) return false
+    if (isSandboxDeploymentEntitled) return true
+    if (!isBillingEnabled) return false
     return await hasMaxTierWorkspaceAccess(workspaceId)
   } catch (error) {
     logger.error('Error checking workspace sandbox access', { error, workspaceId })

apps/sim/lib/core/config/enterprise-entitlements.test.ts

@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ import {
   ENTERPRISE_FEATURE_LEGACY_DEFAULTS,
   type EnterpriseFeature,
   resolveEnterpriseEntitlement,
+  resolveSandboxFeatureAvailability,
 } from '@/lib/core/config/enterprise-entitlements'
 
 describe('resolveEnterpriseEntitlement', () => {
@@ -110,6 +111,49 @@ describe('resolveEnterpriseEntitlement', () => {
       expect(ENTERPRISE_FEATURE_LEGACY_DEFAULTS.accessControl).toBe(false)
       expect(ENTERPRISE_FEATURE_LEGACY_DEFAULTS.organizations).toBe(false)
       expect(ENTERPRISE_FEATURE_LEGACY_DEFAULTS.sso).toBe(false)
+      expect(ENTERPRISE_FEATURE_LEGACY_DEFAULTS.sandboxes).toBe(false)
     })
   })
 })
+
+describe('resolveSandboxFeatureAvailability', () => {
+  it.each([
+    {
+      name: 'hosted billing with a provider',
+      billingEnabled: true,
+      deploymentEntitled: false,
+      remoteProviderEnabled: true,
+      expected: true,
+    },
+    {
+      name: 'hosted billing without a provider',
+      billingEnabled: true,
+      deploymentEntitled: false,
+      remoteProviderEnabled: false,
+      expected: false,
+    },
+    {
+      name: 'billing-free Enterprise or feature entitlement with a provider',
+      billingEnabled: false,
+      deploymentEntitled: true,
+      remoteProviderEnabled: true,
+      expected: true,
+    },
+    {
+      name: 'billing-free provider credentials without an entitlement',
+      billingEnabled: false,
+      deploymentEntitled: false,
+      remoteProviderEnabled: true,
+      expected: false,
+    },
+    {
+      name: 'billing-free entitlement without a provider',
+      billingEnabled: false,
+      deploymentEntitled: true,
+      remoteProviderEnabled: false,
+      expected: false,
+    },
+  ])('$name resolves to $expected', ({ expected, ...input }) => {
+    expect(resolveSandboxFeatureAvailability(input)).toBe(expected)
+  })
+})